In March 2021, I hosted a fascinating discussion on the stormy, co-opted, polarizing online media environment with Georgetown Internet scholar Renee DiResta, Tristan Harris of the Center for Humane Technology and Jeff Orlowski, the director of the hit 2020 Netflix documentary The Social Dilemma (not to mention Chasing Ice, Chasing Coral, Chasing Time).
We explored the film and issues that now seem a bit tame given how much more co-opted and polarizing online discourse has become, but still provides a useful milestone. I wanted to be sure it’s in the Sustain What archive here.
A particularly fascinating section came when Harris described what he saw as a pivotal and, yes, depressing revelation about the gulf between the public interest on the Web and corporate interests. It came around 2007-8 and involved me, my Dot Earth blog, The New York Times, Google and others.
The Times was the first customer for a startup he created called Apture. I remember my excitement when this skinny young Silicon Valley guy showed up at our headquarters to pitch his product. My blog had become something of a crash-test dummy for new stuff. The company had built a plug-in for websites that created a pop-up bubble when a reader scrolled over a link. I loved it. This Times blog post shows why:
We’ve enabled a new feature called Apture on select New York Times blogs: Dot Earth, Economix and Diner’s Journal. Apture allows readers to dig deeper into a subject without ever leaving the page. In a blog post like this, when you see a hyperlink with a small icon next to it, click on that link. You’ll instantly see related videos, maps, documents, photos, New York Times topic pages1 and other content, all while staying on the same page.
Apture ultimately evidently didn’t meet The Times’ goals for boosting time on site. It’s hard to find any trace since Google bought the company. Tristan Harris has gone on to far bigger and more important things and is a keystone voice in AI governance discussions right now (here, here and here via Center for Humane Technology).
More on that soon.
Listen here if you can’t watch or listen to the whole show on a podcast platform or above.
This and the loss of Times Topics Pages (see the footnote) and so much more since then is the Cory Doctorow slide to enshittification.
I encourage you to consider chipping in to sustain what I’m doing here if you can afford it (and I know not a lot of folks can these days, given the world of paywalls out there)
And SHARE what I’m doing with others. That’s the best way to build our Sustain What community.
Ah, Topics Pages… Long extinct for the same reason The Times dumped Apture. I tweeted about this awhile back, writing:
When I was at The New York Times, I pushed for us to maintain what were called “Topics Pages” - pages readers found when they clicked on a highlighted phrase like #climatechange or the name of a country or the like. They were maintained by reporters, kind of the way Wikipedians maintain Wikipedia entries. I maintained the climate change page.
As The Times education team noted years ago, “Teachers tell us that Times Topics pages are great places to go to learn about specific topics quickly and easily-and arguably a better starting place for research than the site search engine.”
This approach allowed curious readers to click and immediately understand what The Times meant when it used such a phrase. But of course that took work.
Now when you click on climate change link in a Times story it just leads you to more Times storiess on climate change - without letting readers know if the paper is using the IPCC or UNFCCC definition or has its own.










